|
|
||||||||
Address correspondence to Tracy L. Marx, DO, CMD, Assistant Professor, Department of Geriatric Medicine/Gerontology, Ohio University College of Osteopathic Medicine, Grosvenor Hall 346, Athens, OH 45701-2979. E-mail: marx{at}ohiou.edu
People are living longer but are dying with more disabilities, often in nursing homes. Identification of those who are dying needs to be quicker to allow discussion of goals of care and to meet their individual needs at a higher level. Pain is pervasive and undertreated in general, but institutionalized individuals are even at greater risk of receiving inadequate analgesia. Competing goals of providing good-quality palliative care while meeting federal and state expectations of improving or maintaining function can create dilemmas for those caring for terminally ill patients in nursing homes. Physicians play a critical role in improving communication between the family and the healthcare team during the transition from rehabilitative to palliative care. Hospice can be a valuable partner in the delivery of excellent pain and symptom management in end-of-life care.
| Case Presentation |
|---|
|
|
|---|
After a lengthy family conference, Mrs White decided not to pursue any further chemotherapy or radiation. She wants to focus on symptom management to maximize her quality of life. She realizes that she can no longer live independently, thus nursing home placement is selected. Mrs White attempts physical and occupational therapy at the nursing home, but the severe pain in her hip is limiting her involvement. Pain medications ordered by her orthopedic surgeon are inadequate. She is unable to sleep, has a poor appetite, and is complaining of excruciating pain radiating down her left leg. The nurse pages Dr Jones to address Mrs White's pain and symptoms and asks, "Why are we pushing her to do therapy? Is rehab really appropriate? Can't we do something to make her more comfortable?" Clearly, these issues are not going to be handled easily over the phone.
Providing palliative care to a patient like Mrs White is a complex task. Physicians have a critical role in improving communication between the family and the healthcare team, making the transition from rehabilitative to palliative care. Hospice can be a valuable partner to deliver excellent pain and symptom management in end-of-life care.
| Dying With Pain and Disability |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Many studies indicate that the rates of untreated severe pain are high among the general nursing home population.3-8
Teno et al3 report that on their initial assessment, 41% of nursing home residents were in pain. Inadequate assessments, as well as the high proportion of cognitively impaired patients, lead to an underestimation of the prevalence of pain. In 1995, Ferrell6 reported that up to 80% of nursing home residents had pain that contributes materially to functional impairment and decreased quality of life. Trask et al9 also reported high percentages of distressing pain observed in individuals transitioning from hospital to the nursing home at the end-of-life. Physicians must ensure that the rapidly increasing numbers of patients who are dying in long-term-care facilities receive good-quality care by incorporating sound palliative care practice.
Teno et al3 found that 25% of newly admitted nursing home residents were in daily pain and 67% of them were still in pain 2 to 6 months later. Bernabei et al5 reported that up to 40% of elderly nursing home patients with cancer had daily pain, and more than 25% of these patients received no analgesics. Several studies found that the elderly were less likely to receive opiates than younger patients.5,10 Buchanan et al7 showed that among recently admitted hospice patients, more than 70% had pain, with almost half having it daily.
Pain is poorly understood because of the lack of objective biologic markers. It is commonly defined as an individual's unpleasant sensory and emotional experience and can profoundly diminish a person's quality of life. Effective pain assessment and management involve an interdisciplinary approach to treat patients for physical, psychological, social, and spiritual symptoms. Pain, a pervasive symptom throughout end-of-life care regardless of diagnosis, is under-treated in general; institutionalized patients are at even greater risk of inadequate treatment for pain. To improve their ability to treat pain, physicians not only must rely on a patient's self-report, but also must have good assessment tools, especially for those patients unable to communicate their needs.
| Overview of Palliative Care and Hospice |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Hospice is a program that provides palliative care by attending to the emotional and spiritual needs of terminally ill patients through an interdisciplinary team approach. The late Dr Cicely Saunders started the modern hospice movement. She was a nurse who became a social worker and then a physician. She taught physicians, nurses, counselors, chaplains, and therapists how to work together to provide comprehensive care at the end of life.
A recent study by Pleschberger12 looked at dying nursing home residents' concerns regarding dignity. Residents were most concerned by the threat of illness and by not having their care needs met, which was fostered by their perception of inadequate care in nursing homes. This investigation highlights the challenges of dying in nursing homes and demonstrates the high vulnerability of this population. Palliative care or hospice services can provide additional support in the nursing home environment.
| Determining Hospice Eligibility |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Clearly, prognosticating death is difficult for most physicians. Abicht-Swensen and Debner15 identified predictors of short-term mortality in nursing home residents independent of age, gender, and diagnosis which include:
These common factors are clinically useful to help identify in a timelier manner those patients who might be hospice eligible.
Deaths due to cancer may be easier to predict because of the typically slow steady decline in function. It is more difficult to predict the death of patients with chronic progressive diseases such as congestive heart disease (CHF), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and other end-stage diseases because of the waxing and waning of acute symptoms. The possibility exists that any acute episode could be fatal. For example, patients with CHF who have a poor ejection fraction and symptoms at rest, while optimally treated with medicine, qualify for hospice care. In the case example, Mrs White is appropriate for palliative care or referral to hospice as she has chosen not to pursue additional treatment.
| Challenges to Palliative Care in Nursing Homes |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Other challenges in providing high-quality long-term care include high staff turnover, staffing shortages, and lack of available hospice teams. Parker-Oliver17 found that the high turnover rate in nursing home staff created communication and coordination problems with the hospice plans of care. Miller et al18 reported that inadequate staff and staff turnover adversely affects the continuity of care and, in turn, the quality of end-of-life care. These effects are more prevalent in nursing homes than in other care settings.
Although the vast majority of nursing homes have access to rehabilitation services, not all have hospice contracts. Parker-Oliver and Bickel19 noted that almost 20% of facilities that they surveyed did not have a hospice contract. At least one nursing home administrator did not contract with hospice for fear that the facility would encounter difficulty at survey time.
Hanson et al20 found that nursing home administrators' attitudes towards hospice may influence its availability for their residents. Nursing home administrators with two or fewer hospice enrollees in the preceding 3 months were three times more likely to indicate that nursing homes were able to provide good care for dying residents and their families without the use of hospice than those administrators with three or more hospice enrollees (37% vs 11%). Despite fewer enrollees, 59% of this cohort indicated that hospice improves quality of care. The study by Hanson and colleagues20 suggests that those nursing home administrators with positive attitudes toward hospice were associated with greater use of hospice by residents in their facilities.
Despite the positive impact hospice has on quality of care through improved pain management and lower hospitalization rates, considerable variation in utilization exists between facilities as well as between states.21 In 2004, the National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care22 developed clinical guidelines based on the collective scientific evidence to promote consistency, comprehensiveness, and quality across many domains of healthcare. These clinical practice guidelines are briefly summarized in Figure 1.
|
| Opportunity for Collaboration—Role of Hospice in Long-term Care |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Better Pain and Symptom Control |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the nursing home setting, the prevalence of dementia, multiplicity of pain problems, and greater sensitivity to drug adverse events pose greater difficulty in assessing and managing pain.6 Miller et al18 note that in the general nursing home population, 56% of residents are either moderately or severely cognitively impaired. Nursing staff's astuteness and reliance on changes in patterns of residents' behavior enable detection of pain or other changes in their condition.18 This vulnerable population is even more prone to inadequate pain and symptom management. Mitchell et al31 found that patients with advanced dementia who were admitted to nursing homes had greater functional disability, more behavior problems, and more often had total parenteral nutrition at the end of life than those who were cared for at home. Healthcare providers often did not recognize that patients were dying, and infrequent referrals were made to hospice. Dying patients were frequently hospitalized, underwent burdensome treatments, and had distressing symptoms that were potentially treatable when death was imminent.31
Families feel that hospice improved the quality of life for their loved ones.32 Baer and Hanson26 reviewed family perceptions of hospice. Respondents rated quality of care for pain and other physical symptoms as good or excellent for 64% of patients before hospice services; after initiation of hospice, this rating increased to 93% of patients. Hospice initiation increased quality of care for emotional and spiritual needs likewise up to 90% from 64%. Families did not perceive nursing home and hospice staff as duplicative. The median estimated added daily monetary value of nursing home hospice was $75, with 45% of family respondents estimating this value at $100 or more per day.26
| Improved Resource Utilization |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Pyenson et al34 confirmed that Medicare costs were lower for patients enrolled in hospice care and that hospice patients lived longer than their nonhospice cohort. For example, caring for a Medicare patient with CHF costs approximately $9,000 less with hospice care; median time until death was lengthened from 65 days to 136 days.34 Further research is needed to explore this finding as this study was designed to look at cost, not length of life.
| Suggestions for Improving End-of-Life Care |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Education on pain management and regulatory guidelines that govern health-care is essential. Physicians can become involved to help shape future healthcare policy. Taking on the role of patient advocate helps ensure open communication with patients and families, nursing home staff, as well as referring physicians. Consultation with the receiving physician across different healthcare settings is crucial to foster a smooth transition to ensure that a patient's goals of care are followed. Figure 3 outlines the physician's role in end-of-life care decision making regarding hospice care. In addition to assuring Mrs White's symptoms are managed, it is her physician's role to facilitate a family meeting with the nursing home staff to discuss goals of care and to explore if hospice would be an appropriate option to meet her wishes.
|
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
An accurate prognosis is essential to good palliative care in the long-term-care setting.21 Depending on that prognosis, nursing home patients require one of the following:
Just as therapists are available in nursing homes to provide rehabilitation, hospice is available for palliation.19 Baer and Hanson26 summarize that initiation of hospice in a "relatively resource-poor" nursing home helps to meet the needs of its dying residents without incurring the additional expense of hospitalizations and other costly interventions. Primary care physicians must recognize the dying process in their frail nursing home patients and ensure that they receive the specialized care needed to assure good pain and symptom management. Hospice can provide such care. We need to be well trained in the holistic approach to medicine. The optimal place to apply this training and approach is in dealing with dying patients and their families.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2. Teno JM, Clarridge BR, Casey V, Welch LC, Wetle T, Shield R, et al.
Family perspectives on end-of-life care at the last place of care.
JAMA. 2004;291:88
-93.
3. Teno JM, Bird C, Mor V. The prevalence and treatment of pain in US nursing homes. 2002, The Center for Gerontology and Health Care Research, Brown University, Providence, RI. Available at: http://www.chcr.brown.edu/dying/factsondying.htm. Accessed March 1, 2007.
4. Miller SC, Mor V, Teno J. Hospice enrollment and pain assessment and management in nursing homes. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2003;26:791 -799.[Medline]
5. Bernabei R, Gambassi G, Lapane K, Landi F, Gatsonis C, Dunlop R, et
al. Management of pain in elderly patients with cancer.
JAMA. 1998;279:1877
-1882.
6. Ferrell BA. Pain evaluation and management in the nursing home.
Ann Intern Med.1995; 123:681
-687.
7. Buchanan RJ, Choi M, Wang S, Huang C. Analyses of nursing home
residents in hospice care using the minimum data set. Palliat
Med. 2002;16:465
-480.
8. Tarzian AJ, Hoffmann DE. Barriers to managing pain in the nursing home: Findings from a statewide survey. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2005;6(3 suppl): S13-S19.[Medline]
9. Trask PC, Teno JM, Nash J. Transitions of care and changes in distressing pain. J Pain Symptom Manage.2006; 32(2):104 -109.[Medline]
10. Kayser-Jones JS, Kris AE, Miaskowski CA, Lyons WL, Paul SM. Hospice
care in nursing homes: Does it contribute to higher quality pain management?
Gerontologist.2006; 46:325
-333.
11. World Health Organization. WHO definition of palliative care. Available at: http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/definition/en/. Accessed March 1, 2007.
12. Pleschberger S. Dignity and the challenge of dying in nursing
homes: The residents' view. Age Ageing.2007; 36: 197-202.
Epub January 4, 2007.
13. National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization. 2005 NHPCO National Data Set Summary Report. 2006. Available at: http://www.nhpco.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=3367. Accessed February 25, 2007.
14. Reynolds K, Henderson M, Schulman A, Hanson LC. Needs of the dying in nursing homes. J Palliat Med.2002; 5:895 -901.[Medline]
15. Abicht-Swensen LM, Debner LK. The Minimum Data Set 2.0: a
functional assessment to predict mortality in nursing home residents.
Am J Hosp Palliat Care.1999; 16:527
-532.
16. National Long Term Care Ombudsman Resource Center. Available at: http://www.ltcombudsman.org/ombpublic/49_346_1023.cfm. Accessed February 27, 2007.
17. Parker-Oliver D. Hospice experience and perceptions in nursing homes. J Palliat Med.2002; 5:713 -720.[Medline]
18. Miller SC, Teno JM, Mor V. Hospice and palliative care in nursing homes. Clin Geriatr Med.2004; 20:717 -734.[Medline]
19. Parker-Oliver D, Bickel D. Nursing home experience with hospice. J Am Med Dir Assoc.2002; 3:46 -50.[Medline]
20. Hanson LC, Sengupta S, Slubicki M. Access to nursing home hospice: Perspectives of nursing home and hospice administrators. J Palliat Med. 2005b;8:1207 -1213.[Medline]
21. Parker-Oliver D, Porock D, Zweig S. End-of-life care in U.S. nursing homes: a review of the evidence. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2004;5:147 -155.[Medline]
22. National Consensus Project for Quality Palliative Care. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Quality Palliative Care. 2004. Available at: http://www.nationalconsensusproject.org/index.html. Accessed February 17, 2005.
23. Hodgson N, Landsberg L, Lehning A, Kleban M. Palliative care services in pennsylvania nursing homes. J Palliat Med.2006; 9:1054 -1058.[Medline]
24. Miller SC, Mor V. The opportunity for collaborative care provision: the presence of nursing home/hospice collaborations in the U.S. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2004;28:537 -547.[Medline]
25. Medicare Payment Advisory Commisssion. Report to the Congress: Medicare Beneficiaries' Access to Hospice. 2002. Washington, DC: p MedPAC; 2002a. Available at: http://www.medpac.gov/publications/congressional_reports/May2002_HospiceAccess.pdf. Accessed March 1, 2007.
26. Baer WM, Hanson LC, Families' perception of the added value of hospice in the nursing home. J Am Geriatr Soc.2000; 48:879 -882.[Medline]
27. Miller SC, Mor V, Wu N, Gozalo P, Lapane K. Does receipt of hospice care in nursing homes improve the management of pain at the end of life? J Am Geriatr Soc.2002; 50:507 -515.[Medline]
28. Wu N, Miller SC, Lapane K, Gozalo P. The problem of assessment bias when measuring the hospice effect on nursing home residents' pain. J Pain Symptom Manage.2003; 26:998 -1009.[Medline]
29. Hanson LC, Reynolds KS, Henderson M, Pickard CG. A quality improvement intervention to increase palliative care in nursing homes.J Palliat Med. 2005a;8:576 -584.[Medline]
30. Wu N, Miller SC, Lapane K, Roy J, Mor V. The quality of the quality indicator of pain derived from the minimum data set. Health Serv Res. 2005;40:1197 -1216.[Medline]
31. Mitchell SL, Morris JN, Park PS, Fries BE. Terminal Care for Persons with Advanced Dementia in the Nursing home and home care settings. J Palliat Med.2004; 7:808 -816.[Medline]
32. Wetle T, Shield R, Teno J, Miller SC, Welch L. Family perspectives
on end-of-life care experiences in nursing homes.
Gerontologist.2005; 45:642
-650.
33. Miller SC, Gozalo P, Mor V. Hospice enrollment and hospitalization of dying nursing home patients. Am J Med.2001; 111:38 -44.[Medline]
34. Pyenson B, Connor S, Fitch K, Kinzbrunner B. Medicare cost in matched hospice and non-hospice cohorts. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2004;28:200 -210.[Medline]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |